There’s a Price to Pay for Being “Fair” as a Boss

The boss talks
© Photographer: Corepics Vof | Agency:

Bosses who are fair make their workers happier and their companies more productive, but in the end may be burning themselves out.

A new study led by Michigan State University’s Russell E. Johnson found the act of carefully monitoring the fairness of workplace decisions wears down supervisors mentally and emotionally.

“Structured, rule-bound fairness, known as procedural justice, is a double-edged sword for managers,” said Johnson, assistant professor of management. “While beneficial for their employees and the organization, it’s an especially draining activity for managers. In fact, we found it had negative effects for managers that spilled over to the next workday.”

For the study, published in the Journal of Applied Psychology, the researchers surveyed 82 bosses twice a day for a few weeks. Managers who reported mental fatigue from situations involving procedural fairness were less cooperative and socially engaging with other workers the next day.

“Managers who are mentally fatigued are more prone to making mistakes and it is more difficult for them to control deviant or counterproductive impulses,” Johnson said. “Several studies have even found that mentally fatigued employees are more likely to steal and cheat.”

Johnson said procedural justice is mentally fatiguing is because it requires managers to conform to particular fairness rules, such as suppressing personal biases, being consistent over time and across subordinates, and allowing subordinates to voice their concerns.

Employees may be concerned about not having personal input into a decision, skeptical about whether accurate information was used to make decisions or resentful over not receiving the same consideration as another more favored employee.

“Essentially managers have to run around making sure their subordinates’ perceptions remain positive, whether the threat to the atmosphere of the workplace is real or imagined. Dealing with all of this uncertainty and ambiguity is depleting,” Johnson said.

Managers who are fair cannot realistically avoid some burnout, he added. They just need to create situations in which they are better prepared to cope with the fatigue and overcome it.

Tips for managers include getting sufficient sleep, taking short mental breaks during the workday, adhering to a healthy diet and detaching from work completely when outside of the office – for example, not reading email or memos at home after 7 p.m.



Share this post through your social networks!

Follow the Magazine:

(After you have filled in your email address in the column at the right hand side of the screen, a confirmation email will sent to your email address. You will have to confirm it before subscription begins. Subscription is FREE)

Follow us on Twitter:

Like us on Facebook:

**As part of the Magazine’s drive to reward subscribers/followers, we will be providing subscribers/followers special access to exclusive content which will not be otherwise available to normal visitors. Please be sure to subscribe to the Magazine. Many visitors have given us positive comments that they will be bookmarking the site, but as the system is unable to capture a working email address to which the passcodes for exclusive content will be sent, they will miss out on this content. Do note that passcodes are locked to each exclusive content, not a one-for-all access, so do provide a working email address that you check regularly so as not to miss out on them!


One thought on “There’s a Price to Pay for Being “Fair” as a Boss

  1. This is an excellent article and I will pass it on. This is what I would call an “awareness message”. First it affirms, at least for me, that playing fair in the workplace is essential. Then, it points out that there is a price to be paid for being fair in all things. Of course, leadership – being the “boss” – always has costs associated with it. The key to success is managing those costs, one of which is the risk of ‘burnout”. From experience I have come to understand that some people will think it is great that you work for fairness and justice. Others will resent you for it and actually undermine your efforts. You are served to embrace this and make it alright with yourself that, as a leader or a manager, you will always have detractors (usually in significant numbers). Treat this awareness as the cup being half full rather than half empty. Recognize that many people are positively behind your action. If you can take strength from the surety that you are doing what is right you will prevail and, actually, grow stronger from each act of fairness. Hence, your believe in the power of fairness to create a quality workplace can become, in itself, the deterrent to “burnout”. Like all leadership concepts, this one grows stronger from focused exercise. It is, afterall, about the quality of your own “self-talk”. Warm Regards, Dr. Ed

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s